Why sustainable packaging choices rarely have a simple answer

From product choice to a systems perspective
The debate around sustainable packaging often starts with a seemingly simple question: Is reusable always better than single-use? Reusable solutions have significant potential to reduce resource use and waste, particularly when packaging is returned and used many times within an efficient system. But the environmental benefits do not arise simply because a product is designed for reuse. They also depend on how many times the product is actually used and how collection, transportation, washing and redistribution are managed.
“Discussions often focus on the product itself, but what determines the outcome is how the entire solution works in practice. It is the interaction between the product, the user and the infrastructure that creates the actual impact. That is why this is a systems issue,” says Erik Lindroth, Sustainability Director at Duni Group.
The packaging debate has intensified as sustainability requirements have increased, changing customer expectations and new legislation has been introduced. The EU Packaging and Packaging Waste Regulation (PPWR) is driving the transition toward less packaging waste and more circular systems through requirements covering areas such as packaging minimization, reuse and recyclability. At the same time, companies need to assess how different solutions work in the relevant use case and in practice. Functionality, logistics, return flows, access to relevant infrastructure and how people actually use the solution are all factors that influence the outcome.
Different use cases require different systems
What works well in a staff restaurant may not work equally well for takeaway, home delivery or large public events. Different use cases create different conditions for collection, return and reuse.
Reusable solutions often have good potential in environments where packaging can easily be collected and used again. But a clearly defined setting alone does not guarantee a successful reuse system. The solution also needs to be easy to use, have sufficient capacity and create the conditions for each package to be reused enough times. The user perspective is therefore an important part of the overall picture.
In open environments, where people take food or beverages to different locations, achieving a consistently high return rate can be more challenging. This places greater demands on the accessibility of return points, user incentives, transportation between locations and coordination between restaurants, system operators and other stakeholders.
Different packaging formats also create different handling requirements. Cups and food containers, for example, may differ in terms of contamination, stacking, storage, washing, transportation and food safety. Handling and capacity therefore need to be adapted to both the characteristics of the packaging and the context in which it is used.
For restaurants, catering operators and other foodservice businesses, a packaging solution must also meet requirements for functionality, food safety and operational efficiency. A solution that is difficult to use or integrate into daily operations may fail to deliver the intended impact, even if it has strong potential in theory.
Operational feasibility should therefore not be seen as an alternative to sustainability, but as a prerequisite for putting sustainability ambitions into practice and scaling them over time.
Systems need to reflect how people actually behave
How people use, return and sort packaging has a significant impact on the outcome in practice. Sustainable solutions therefore need to be designed around real behaviors, not only technical possibilities.
User behavior is not an isolated factor. It is influenced by how the solution is designed. Accessibility, cost, incentives, clear information and ease of use can determine whether people do what is required for the solution to work.
“People do not always choose the option they say they prefer. Instead, they weigh sustainability against factors such as convenience and cost. Sustainable solutions therefore need to work in everyday life, not just in theory. Sweden’s deposit return system is one example that demonstrates the value of combining infrastructure and clear incentives with a solution that is established and easy to understand,” says Erik Lindroth.
For a solution to work at scale, the desired behavior needs to be easy. A reusable solution, for example, needs return points in locations that people actually use. Single-use packaging needs clear sorting information and a collection and recycling system capable of handling the material. In both cases, it is the combination of product, information and infrastructure that creates the conditions for a better outcome.
Products and systems continue to evolve
Neither single-use nor reusable solutions are uniform categories. Two products within the same category can differ significantly in terms of material use, weight, functionality, lifespan and their potential for reuse or recycling.
For single-use packaging, developments have led to lighter designs, more mono-material solutions and designs better suited to sorting and recycling. In parallel, reuse solutions continue to evolve through new business models, digital traceability, more accessible return solutions and more efficient handling.
These developments create new opportunities, but they do not change the fundamental principle: every solution needs to be assessed based on how it performs under real-world conditions.
For companies, sustainable packaging choices are therefore less about choosing between two categories and more about understanding the conditions required for a solution to work in practice.
Packaging does not become circular simply because it is technically recyclable or designed for reuse. Circularity only occurs when the material is collected and recycled, or when the product is returned and actually reused. The discussion therefore needs to move away from broad categories and toward verifiable outcomes in specific use cases. A product is not circular in itself; it needs to be part of a functioning circular system.
The future requires more than one solution
As regulation and market requirements evolve, reuse will play a greater role in applications where efficient systems for return, washing and redistribution can be established. In these cases, the ambition should be to remove practical barriers and make reuse simple and scalable.
At the same time, there will continue to be applications where the conditions for a functioning reusable system are limited. In these cases, the focus should be on minimizing material use, ensuring the necessary functionality and food safety, and selecting solutions that are adapted to the actual collection and recycling infrastructure.
The packaging market of the future is therefore unlikely to be defined by a single product or model. Different solutions will need to work in parallel and continue to evolve as requirements, technologies and consumer behaviors change. The challenge for companies will be to monitor actual outcomes and continuously adapt their solutions to the needs and conditions of their operations.
As a supplier of both reusable and resource-efficient single-use solutions, Duni Group works with businesses that have different needs and operating conditions. Our ambition is to contribute knowledge, perspectives and solutions that help customers and partners make informed decisions over time.
Downloads
Contact information
Petra Lamorell
Interim Head of Communications
+46 (0)76-8 740 387
[email protected]


